I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Learn more.

Metal vs. Molded Baseball Cleats (vs. Turf Shoes)

When getting ready for their baseball journey, most people have a hard time deciding what tools and wardrobe essentials they should get.

Most of these wardrobe pieces like protection gear and cleats are quite an investment.

They are expensive, so people want to make a good decision in the first place instead of frequently replacing things.

Amidst this process, one of the most prevalent debates is about metal vs. molded baseball cleats.

Shoes play an essential role in providing safety for the player, improving their performance, and helping them do their best in the field.

So naturally, the choice of these shoes can make or break a baseball player’s entire career.

If you have never bought baseball shoes before, let me help you.

I am going to elaborate on the different types of shoes, their pros, and cons, and help you decide which ones you should get.

Metal Vs. Molded Baseball Cleats – What’s The Difference

Metal Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
Molded Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
-
-
Metal Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
-
Molded Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
-

Last update on 2021-09-16 at 20:46 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

When we talk about baseball cleats, the difference is in the studs under their soles.

Those studs are either made of metal or mold, and both these types have individual characteristics, pros, and cons.

The primary differences between metal and molded baseball cleats are the following:

Material

The most apparent difference between metal and molded cleats is that they are both made from different materials.

Metal studs are usually made from high-quality metal.

Some metal cleats also have rubber caps. In the case of molded cleats, these studs can be either rubber or plastic.

Traction

Both metal and molded cleats provide different levels of traction, and in this case, metal cleats win.

Since metal is sharp, thin, and strong, it digs deeper into the grass or mud and gives better support and traction to the player.

In contrast, molded cleats do not have sharp studs. Thus, they do not provide as much traction as metal cleats do.

Position Player

Since they provide different levels of support and are ideal for different kinds of fields, both metal, and molded cleats are suitable for different player positions.

For example, pitchers and infielders usually use metal cleats because they require more maneuverability and traction during the game.

In contrast, outfielders prefer molded cleats because their roles, movements, and requirements are different.

Safety

Metal cleats are not safe for younger players. This is because these studs have sharp ends and can cause injury during the game.

So naturally, in many leagues, metal cleats are not even approved.

However, molded cleats are much safer since they don’t have sharp ends.

Therefore, their acceptance and approval rate is much higher.

Durability

Durability is vital in such footwear because these cleats are expensive and are a long-term investment.

When you spend so much money on baseball equipment or anything else in general, you want to make the most out of it and wish it would last long.

When put side-by-side, metal cleats have better durability compared to molded ones.

Therefore, professional players who want to invest in longer-lasting cleats should get metal ones.

However, younger players, who are still learning to play, should get molded ones.

Versatility

Versatility, in baseball terms, means that you can use the shoes outside the field as well as inside.

As bizarre as it may sound, you cannot wear metal baseball cleats on the plain solid floor as you move from the parking lot to the field and back.

You can only wear them inside the field and on soft muddy, or grassy grounds.

They are cumbersome, noisy, and very uncomfortable to wear on concrete floors and marble tiles.

Molded cleats work well inside the field as well as outside on pavements, roads, and other floors.

Price

Price tags are important because everyone has their own budget they like to stick to.

Metal cleats are usually expensive because of the high-quality metals used in them.

In contrast, molded cleats are generally less costly; you can get a good pair under $40 or so!

Pros And Cons Of Metal Baseball Cleats

Sale
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
1,379 Reviews
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
  • Surface recommendation as firm ground and a low top height
  • Not Water Resistant and a synthetic fabric
  • Cushioned Comfort: This baseball cleat helps you round the bases in comfort with an innovative and durable REVlite...
  • Sleek and Sporty: Featuring a low-profile design with an upper that includes TPU-coated yarns, the 4040v5 baseball cleat...
  • Secure Fit: A traditional lacing system and a soft foam package around the ankle and heel of these cleats help create a...

Last update on 2021-09-16 at 20:46 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Moving on with comparing metal vs. molded baseball cleats, let’s talk about some of the most significant advantages and drawbacks of metal cleats.

Then, depending on your requirements and personal preferences, you can decide what advantages are essential for you and what drawbacks you can compromise on:

Positive
  • They give you great support and traction in the field.
  • They are durable and last very long.
  • High-quality metal studs look very visually appealing.
  • They improve the player’s overall performance.
  • Metal cleats help players train for professional games.
Negative
  • They are expensive compared to other cleats.
  • Metal cleats are not ideal for concrete or solid floors.
  • They have a higher chance of causing injury during the game.

Pros And Cons Of Molded Baseball Cleats

New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
1,974 Reviews
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
  • Traction You Can Trust: These New Balance baseball cleats are equipped with a TPU molded cleat outsole that provides...
  • Breathable and Durable Kids Running Shoes: The synthetic and mesh upper provides incredible breathability and a durable...
  • Durable No-Sew Tip: These New Balance kids' running shoes feature a no-sew tip for durability, in addition to a sleek...
  • The Perfect Fit for Active Kids: This pair of comfortable kids' running shoes provides a solid yet comfortable fit,...
  • Cool Appearance: The crowd-pleasing, athletic styling of these kids' performance shoes will make every step stand out....

Last update on 2021-09-16 at 20:46 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Now, let’s enlist the good and bad sides of molded baseball cleats.

Understanding their pros and cons will give you a better idea of whether you should invest in them:

Positive
  • They are less costly and easily accessible.
  • They pose less danger of injury on the field.
  • They are far easier to walk in.
  • You can wear them on concrete, tiled, and solid floors outside the field.
Negative
  • Molded studs are not as long-lasting.
  • They do not provide the same traction on the field as metal studs do.

Baseball Turf Shoes Vs. Cleats – What’s The Difference?

Turf Shoes
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Turf Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 5 W US
Metal Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
Molded Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Turf Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 5 W US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
-
-
Turf Shoes
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Turf Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 5 W US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Turf Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 5 W US
Metal Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Metal Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 11 M US
-
Molded Cleats
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 TPU Molded Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 8 M US
-

Last update on 2021-09-16 at 20:46 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Apart from the metal vs. molded baseball cleats discussion, another prevalent debate is whether baseball turf shoes are better than baseball cleats.

Again, the two are very different. Each of them has individual characteristics, which makes it ideal for a different situation.

To clarify these differences, let’s talk about them individually:

Traction

Consider the pitch you are playing on. Molded and metal cleats work well on fields with mud and natural grass.

However, turf shoes are better suited for artificial turf because they are designed to give better traction on such surfaces and stay stable and comfortable.

In addition, they give adequate support to the ankle to make sure your joint stays protected.

Hence, turf shoes offer better traction when you are playing on artificial grounds.

Durability

Even though metal cleats are the most durable of all, molded cleats also have a very long lifespan.

They have rubber and plastic spikes that can basically last for years if you take good care of them.

Similarly, turf shoes also have rubber outsoles, so they are incredibly durable and last very long.

This helps maximize the traction for the player and increase their speeds on the turf.

However, it is crucial to understand that other factors also play an essential role in how durable the shoes will be.

These factors include the manufacturing, how well you take care of them, how often you use them, the kind of environment you use them in, and other external factors.

Versatility

Turf shoes are ideal for playing on artificial grounds.

However, since their spikes are smaller and less resistant to damage from solid floors, they are not as great to be worn on external surfaces, and you should avoid doing that.

If you wear them outside the ground (turf), it will weaken the studs, and the lifespan of your shoes will decrease by several folds.

Similarly, cleats should also not be worn outside the ground since their studs are sharp, and their durability will decrease if you use them in an unfavorable environment.

But will they be damaged more than turf shoes?

No. The difference between the two baseball shoes is that cleats will still last longer even if you use them on solid floors.

Price

There is no significant difference between the price ranges of cleats and turf shoes.

The price tags entirely depend on where you are getting the shoes, what design they have, the materials used, and other factors.

Generally speaking, turf shoes are more affordable than cleats and are available at reasonable prices worldwide.

Safety

As molded cleats are relatively safer than metal ones, turf shoes are even less prone to injury because they have smaller spikes that are made of rubber or plastic.

So, any injury they cause is less painful and severe compared to cleats.

Out of all three, these shoes are the safest ones, especially for younger, beginner players.

They also provide excellent support for the ankle, which is why joint twisting injuries, sprains, and strains are less common.

Pros And Cons Of Baseball Turf Shoes

Sale
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Turf Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 5 W US
3,061 Reviews
New Balance Men's 4040 V5 Turf Baseball Shoe, Black/White, 5 W US
  • Synthetic mesh upper with reinforcement in the toe
  • Versatile nubby rubber outsole
  • New TPU plate
  • Support for Your Sport: The lightweight synthetic and mesh upper of these New Balance baseball turf shoes features TPU...
  • Secure Fit: A traditional lace-up system and strategically placed cushioning in these baseball shoes help create a snug,...

Last update on 2021-09-16 at 20:46 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Lastly, let’s look at the advantages and disadvantages of turf shoes.

Doing so will help you choose whether you’d like to buy them:

Positive
  • They provide better traction than regular sneakers and are ideal for variable playing grounds.
  • They are far more comfortable compared to cleats.
  • They are also very lightweight compared to cleats.
  • Turf shoes work well in both indoor and outdoor environments.
  • They help improve the player’s performance on artificial turf.
  • They reduce the chances of an ankle injury.
Negative
  • Turf shoes have a higher incidence of toe injuries compared to cleats.

Can You Wear Baseball Cleats On Turf?

As we have discussed earlier, the features and designs of cleats and turf shoes are very different.

These individual characteristics make them ideal for different environments and floors.

Whether they are metal or molded, baseball cleats have sharper studs that are best for digging into grounds.

Because of this particular characteristic, these cleats are ideal for natural grounds with grass, mud, and sand.

If you wear these cleats on artificial turf or solid floors and tiles, they will slip and cause both discomfort and injury.

Even cleats with rubber ends are not ideal for artificial turf and cannot replace turf shoes.

And so, to answer your question: no, you cannot wear baseball cleats on turf.

If you do, not only will they be very uncomfortable, but they can also cause slippage, fall, and trauma.

What Are Interchangeable Baseball Cleats?

Interchangeable baseball studs can solve all your problems if you are confused about which ones to get.

As the name suggests, these shoes have interchangeable studs underneath them, meaning that you can apply and remove the studs of your choice as needed.

You can put on metal studs when you need them in the field or replace them with molded ones if the circumstances change.

Interchangeable studs usually come with screw designs, so you can quickly and easily remove them and put the new ones on.

Since these are more technical, advanced, and functional than metal and molded cleats, be prepared to see a heftier price tag!

But if you have the budget for them, I would personally suggest you get these.

If you find good-quality interchangeable cleats that will last you a long time and solve most of your problems, every penny is worth it!

So, if you are unsure whether you want to invest in metal cleats or molded ones, interchangeable baseball shoes can make your life much easier.

They can give you the best of both worlds in a single investment.

In addition, you won’t have to change your shoes repeatedly; just change the studs, and you are ready to go!

It saves time, energy and is a hassle-free way to play baseball in various roles.

In Conclusion

The metal vs. molded baseball cleats discussion does not have a definitive answer, and seeking the “correct answer” will lead you nowhere.

Instead, look for the most appropriate choice for you, depending on your position, preferences, and requirements.

Think about whether turf shoes, metal cleats, or molded baseball footgear will be appropriate for you in the field.

Consider the differences between these different types of footwear and remember their pros and cons when you go shopping.

Having proper knowledge and information about all your options can help you make the right choice!

Little Ballparks
Logo